Lessons at the School by the Sea
by Jenny Colgan
Although there were two boys’ boarding schools in my home town in the the U.S., boarding school seems more important in British history and culture than it is in the United States. Jenny Colgan originally wrote this series about a pair of neighboring boys’ and girls’ boarding schools in Great Britain under a pen name at her publisher’s suggestion. They are currently reissuing The School by the Sea Series under the same name as her other popular books.
Having read the first book in the series, I was interested in revisiting the two schools and catching up with the characters. I was disappointed with the pace in Lessons at the School by the Sea. The characters are stymied by their respective roles and are frankly unlikable. There are two storylines. One focuses on the teachers and the other one on a core group of students. The two plot lines in the story overlap.
There is a new character in this addition to the series. Ismé is a scholarship student who keeps her three roommates at arm’s length. Suddenly, one of the roommates questions her own gender and sexual orientation and falls in love with Ismé because of a kiss in a play. The relationship seems contrived and unrealistic.
The only part of the book that truly got my attention is the efforts of David, who has to take a job teaching English literature to high school students at a low income school in a rough part of town. I was interested in his methods to draw the students in. He doesn’t give up even when they resist his attempts to get control so that he can actually teach them. He is somewhat naive but stands by his moral principles and has a positive effect on his students and the whole demoralized school.
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Rating: 3/5
Category: Fiction, Women’s Fiction, Young Adult
Publication: March 7, 2023—Avon and HARPER
Memorable Lines:
“But everyone here is so rich and knows everything and how to get by…” Maggie stared out the window. “Nah,” she said. “They’re faking it just as much as anybody else. Posh people are just better at pretending.”
She couldn’t bear to think that any Downey girl—any student who had ever been in her care—would be capable of doing such a thing. But she knew this was bias, that people did do horrible things on the internet, every single second of the day.
“…if you behaved like a bad person, whatever your intentions, it was entirely possible that you would become one.”
Special Memorable Quote for Those Who Love All Things Bookish:
On Saturday morning she had driven all the way into Exeter, which had the nearest Paperchase, and spent a very happy hour there—like all book lovers, she had a special affinity with stationery and could happily spend half a day among it—choosing the finest, most beautiful writing paper and pen she could find.
As a former teacher, I’m sure parts of this book were interesting, but from your review it’s obvious you were disappointed. The story line does sound confusing…
Jenna
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, I was disappointed. I’ll try other books by this author, but not in this series.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is disappointing that publishers and authors feel the need to insert certain things in books. This sounds like it could have been an interesting story. Unlikeable characters makes it hard for me to continue with a book. Glad there was at least one who had some redeeming qualities. I did enjoy the bookish quote.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Beautiful stationary is not as available now because of technology takeovers. I am as guilty as anyone. It started for me when I lived in Mexico and sending mail was a joke. It was commonly known that mail is rarely received there. E-cards are also so quick and convenient. But there still remains something beautiful about sending physical correspondence.
LikeLike
Too bad this one didn’t live up to the first in the series, Linda, but it sounds like there were some shaving moments. I shy away from books set in schools, as I compare them to my career too much.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good point, but I find in this case there weren’t too many similarities because these are boarding schools. I’m not going to read the next one, however.
LikeLiked by 1 person